Citizen Journalism

Posts Tagged ‘Slot machine’

Life after pokies: A musical solution

In Gambling, Tom Cummings on March 5, 2013 at 12:14 PM
Oakleigh Carnegie RSL

Oakleigh Carnegie RSL

By Tom Cummings (@cyenne40)
March 5, 2013

In New South Wales RSL clubs are synonymous with poker machines. They’ve been part of the furniture for decades, and many NSW RSLs have become sprawling entertainment meccas by riding on the back of gaming machine revenue.

Unlike their northern cousins, however, Victorian RSLs have always had an uneasy relationship with the pokies. Maybe it’s because poker machines were a relatively late addition, only being legalised in Victoria in the early 1990s. Maybe it’s because clubs in Victoria have to play by the same rules as pubs, and don’t have a raft of advantages enshrined in law. Whatever the reason, poker machines have not, in many cases, turned out to be the financial saviour that Victorian RSLs thought they would be.

The reality is that there is not a single RSL in the top 50 Victorian poker machine venues by revenue. In Victoria it is the pubs that make the most money from gambling, while clubs are the poor cousins. Many have struggled to make ends meet, even with poker machines; in fact, the financial burden of operating unprofitable gaming machines has caused a number of RSLs and other clubs to close their doors for good.

But not every RSL has gone down this route. One club that has voluntarily given up its poker machines and sought a different direction is the Oakleigh/Carnegie RSL, and that direction has proven to be a point of difference that no one could have expected.

In 2009, the Oakleigh/Carnegie RSL was struggling to stay afloat. They had 16 poker machines that were costing them more money than they were bringing in, and with changes in the demographic of the local community and an aging membership, the future looked grim. But rather than folding under the financial burden, the RSL made a brave and visionary decision. They got rid of their poker machines and decided to try and survive without them.

At the same time, Peter Foley was looking for a new home for his live music initiative, the Caravan Music Club. The Caravan had been running at the Oakleigh Bowling Club for the past two years and was instrumental in bringing quality live music to the eastern suburbs, but it was rapidly becoming a victim of its own success. As the gigs became bigger and more popular, it became clear that The Caravan needed a new home, one that could sustain a permanent venue and meet the demands of a music-loving public.

The Caravan needed a home; the Oakleigh/Carnegie RSL had an empty hall opening onto a beer garden. In the end, it was as simple as that. And while contemporary, intimate gigs from the likes of Deborah Conway, Stephen Cummings and Don Walker may not seem to be regular musical fare for an RSL, it’s a partnership that has stood the test of time.

The Caravan Club

The Caravan Club

I caught up with Peter Foley  recently and asked him how The Caravan Music Club was travelling at the Oakleigh/Carnegie RSL. Read the rest of this entry »


Life after pokies: A grassroots fightback

In Gambling, Tom Cummings on February 25, 2013 at 11:21 PM
Tom Cummings

Tom Cummings

By Tom Cummings (@cyenne40)
February 25, 2013

There are an awful  lot of pubs and clubs in Australia. I should know; I’ve visited a lot of them. Country clubs, city pubs and everything in between; from Mooloolabah to Blacktown to Bright, and more besides. I’ve spent plenty of time in watering holes up and down the length of Australia’s east coast, and I’ve learned one fundamental truth.

There are two types of pub in Australia, two types of club. Those with poker machines, and those without. No matter how you dress them up with fancy decor and boutique beers, or dress them down with fence-paling bars and chooks out the back, in the end it’s the pokies that are the difference.

Pokies pubs and clubs have a very different atmosphere to their pokie-free cousins. It’s almost a sense of distraction; everyone knows that the pokies are where the money is coming from, even though in many cases they seem embarrassed to admit it. In fact, in a lot of venues (pub venues mainly) the gaming rooms are hidden away, and every effort is made to pretend they don’t exist. Clubs, on the other hand, have a tendency to put their machines smack bang in the middle of everything. It’s hard to convey a sense of community belonging when all around you, money is being siphoned away at high speed.

Now, I freely admit to having a particular bias on this topic. I would much rather walk a mile or two to another venue than give my custom to a pokies pub, and the reason is simple. As a young man, I poured years of my life and thousands upon thousands of dollars into poker machines. I was on the hook, and no amount of wriggling could get me off it until pretty much everything I had and everyone I knew was gone. So these days, older and wiser, I look at the pubs and clubs with their gaming rooms and their glitzy signs, and I walk on.

And I’m not alone in feeling this way. Here in my home state of Victoria, there have been a number of battles waged over the past few years, by residents fighting to slow down or prevent the spread of poker machines into their communities. Romsey’s fight took them to the Supreme Court, Jan Juc marshalled their resistance via Facebook and most recently, Castlemaine won a landmark VCAT decision after years of unified persistence. Sadly though, the truth is that for each of these victories, many more battles are lost, and venues approved… and so the poker machines continue to hold sway.

But it doesn’t have to be that way. Because the reality is that there’s actually a third type of pub out there, a third type of club which is bucking the trend and, essentially, making a stand. These are the venues that had poker machines, that knew what they meant in terms of income and revenue… and said, no more.


These are the venues that have handed back their poker machines, and started life anew. In many ways they’re just like me; they’ve broken free from the addiction that pokies brings, and made a decision to change. It’s a massive decision to make; believe me, when you’ve been on the receiving end of the kind of money poker machines can bring in, it’s damn hard to walk away. But for some people, it was the right thing to do… indeed, it was the only thing to do. Read the rest of this entry »